How to Stop Second-Guessing Decisions at Work
For years, part of my work on employability programmes involved a conversation that went the same way more times than I could count. We would sit down together, find suitable vacancies, go through the criteria line by line and talk through how to approach each application. The person would leave with a short list of roles they were well suited to. A few weeks later we would meet again and I would ask how they had got on with those vacancies. “I didn’t apply for that one, and I didn’t apply for that one either.” When I asked why, the answer was nearly always some version of “I just didn’t feel ready for it.”
What made it so frustrating was that they were ready, at least on paper. We had checked the criteria together and they were ticking most of the boxes. Somewhere between our meeting and the closing date, fear stepped in and made the decision for them. Nobody had consciously turned the opportunity down. The question was simply left open until the deadline closed it on their behalf, and that is what second-guessing decisions looks like in its purest form.
You do not have to be looking for work to recognise this. The same hesitation appears when an internal promotion is advertised and you talk yourself out of applying, when you hold back a recommendation until it feels perfect, or when you sit on a decision about your own next move for another six months. The setting changes from person to person, but the mechanism underneath stays remarkably consistent.

What second-guessing decisions really costs
The cost of a decision left too late is easy to miss, because nothing visibly goes wrong. There is no rejection letter to read and no awkward conversation to recover from. The opportunity quietly passes and work carries on much as before, which is exactly what makes it so expensive. When you apply for a role, you are in the pool and you have a chance. When you do not, the outcome is already settled, and it was settled by you.
I used to put this to people plainly. Applying does not commit you to anything beyond the application itself. You do not have to go for the interview if, on reflection, the role turns out to be wrong for you. What the application does is keep the door open while you find out more. Holding back closes that door before you have had any chance to discover whether you would have wanted to walk through it.
The same logic applies to the decisions professionals make inside organisations every week. McKinsey’s 2019 global survey on decision-making found that 61 per cent of respondents said most of their decision-making time was used ineffectively.
That research looked at organisational decisions rather than personal ones, but I think it points to something broader about how people work. A good deal of the time we describe as “deciding” is really time spent waiting to feel certain. Certainty is not something working life tends to offer, so the waiting stretches on, and the cost builds up in missed opportunities and slower progress that nobody ever records.
Two very different reasons people freeze
In my experience, hesitation at the point of committing tends to come from one of two places, and they need quite different responses. Treating them as the same problem is one reason so much of the advice on this topic falls flat.
The first is the feeling of not being ready, even when the evidence says otherwise. This is the person who meets most of the criteria but focuses entirely on the one or two they are less sure about. In a working context, it is the experienced manager who has been doing elements of the next role for a year yet still feels the promotion belongs to someone more polished.
The gap they worry about is real enough to them, but it is usually much smaller than it feels, and often a gap the employer expects to close through the role itself. I have written before about applying for a job when you feel underqualified, and the same principle holds here. Readiness is something you grow into after the decision, not a condition you must meet before it.
The second reason is harder, and it deserves more compassion than it usually gets.
Some people freeze because they have already had so many rejections that another application feels like volunteering for one more. From the outside, it looks like indecision. From the inside, it is self-protection, and it makes perfect sense. If the last six attempts ended in a polite email saying no, holding back feels like the only way to guarantee you will not be hurt again. The difficulty is that this protection comes at the price of the very outcome the person is hoping for. The same thing can happen inside an organisation after being passed over for promotion, when the next opportunity feels more like a risk than a chance.
There is often a third factor sitting in the background, which is the environment people work in. Where decisions are routinely overruled, criticised without discussion or passed through several layers of approval, second-guessing becomes a learned response rather than a personal flaw. If your judgement has been questioned publicly in the past, it is understandable that you now check everything twice. Recognising where the habit came from does not remove it, but it does stop you treating it as evidence that you cannot be trusted to decide.
Why your gut often knows before your head does
Here is where I part company with a lot of conventional advice on decision-making. I have always encouraged people to go with their gut, because in my experience the first instinct is usually truer than the conclusion reached after turning something over again and again. When people overthink a decision and then act on the later version, it frequently does not work out as well. By that stage the reasoning has been worn down by fear, other people’s opinions and every worst case they could imagine.
This is not simply a personal view. In a well-known 2009 paper in American Psychologist, Daniel Kahneman and Gary Klein set out the conditions under which intuition can be trusted. Their conclusion was that intuitive judgement is reliable when it is built on real experience in a setting where you have had the chance to learn from feedback over time. That describes a mid-career professional far better than it describes a beginner. You have got this far for a reason. Years of work have given you a feel for which opportunities fit, which recommendations will land and which risks are worth taking, and that feel deserves more credit than it usually receives.
Second-guessing is also closely connected to strengths. When a strength is pushed too hard under pressure, Strengthscope describes it as going into overdrive, and the results can look exactly like chronic doubt. Thoroughness in overdrive becomes endless rechecking. Collaboration in overdrive becomes needing everyone’s agreement before you move. Strategic thinking in overdrive becomes keeping every option open long after one of them has clearly won. Understanding which of your strengths tends to tip over in this way is often more useful than any general advice to be more decisive.

Give your gut something solid to stand on
Trusting your instinct does not mean deciding blind. The clients in those employability meetings were not short of information. We had already done the groundwork together, and their first reaction to most of those roles had been positive. The problem only started when they went away and began arguing with it. The lesson is to do the preparation once, properly, and then let your instinct work with what you have gathered.
Start by deciding what matters before you ask anyone else. For a career decision, that might be the scope of the role, the chance to use your strengths, the development it offers and the practical realities of pay and location. Without those criteria, every new opinion reopens the whole question. With them, you can listen to advice without handing your judgement over to the loudest or most recent voice.
When you do seek input, ask for challenge rather than permission. There is a real difference between asking a colleague “What do you think I should do?” and saying “I am leaning towards applying because of these reasons, so what have I missed?” The first invites someone else to make the decision for you. The second keeps you connected to your own thinking while still giving you the benefit of another perspective.
It also helps to be honest about how reversible the decision really is. Very few workplace choices are as final as they feel at the time. An application can be withdrawn, a new approach can be adjusted after a month, and a proposal can be revised once you hear the response. When you recognise that most decisions can be corrected along the way, the pressure to get them perfect before you start begins to ease.
Commit, then stop reopening it
Decisions can stay open in your head long after you have technically made them. You agree on a direction, then revisit it at night, look for fresh reassurance and quietly lose momentum. A clear point of commitment helps enormously here. The application is submitted, the email is sent, or the conversation is booked, and from that moment the question is closed.
After that point, only reopen the decision if genuinely new and material information appears. Feeling anxious is not, by itself, new information. It is usually the normal discomfort of being visible and accountable, and it tends to settle once you are moving rather than waiting. As I argued in [Confidence Isn’t Missing. Evidence Is.](INSERT LINK), confidence tends to follow action far more reliably than it comes before it.

When a pause is the better call
None of this means every decision should be made quickly. A pause is the wiser choice when the consequences are significant and hard to undo, when critical facts are genuinely missing or when you are reacting from frustration or exhaustion. The difference lies between an intentional pause and an open-ended delay. An intentional pause names what you need to find out, who you need to speak to and when you will come back to the decision. An open-ended delay simply allows fear to keep the question alive until the opportunity has gone.
If you notice that your pauses never seem to end, that is worth paying attention to. It may be the first reason at work, the quiet belief that you are not ready yet. It may be the second, the wish to avoid one more disappointment. Either way, naming it honestly is the first step towards a decision you have actually made yourself.
The question worth asking yourself
Think about a decision you are holding open at the moment, whether it is an application, a conversation you have been putting off or a change you keep postponing. Then ask yourself what your instinct said before you started arguing with it. You may find that the answer was there all along, and that the weeks of reconsidering have only made it harder to hear. You have got this far through your own judgement. The real question is whether you are prepared to trust it again now, while the opportunity is still there.
If you would like a clearer picture of the strengths you rely on when decisions get difficult, and how they behave under pressure, a Strengthscope Profile with 360 Feedback gives you that insight. It is a practical starting point for making decisions with more confidence, because it shows you what you already bring.
By Paula Donnan
Strength at Work | Better judgement. Stronger leadership. Higher performance.
If this is affecting you, book in for a free 30-minute initial briefing to discuss the way forward.



Comments